BALTIMORE STANDING TOGETHER: Watch town hall Wednesday at 6:30 p.m. on WJZ, as leaders address issues the city is facing.

By: CBS Detroit Blogger Eric Thomas

(CBS Detroit) Ray Lewis seems poised to ride into the sunset like Jerome Bettis if the Ravens win in the linebacker’s second championship game. Lewis looms large in a Super Bowl without superstars and gets the reflected glow of the big game. That spotlight exposes some gnarly fissures on him; some scabbed over scars of whispers and rumor. Self righteous types cluck their tongues to this day and mouth the word: “Murderer.”

His trial was thirteen years ago, so memories faded. When facts fall out of the mouths of commentators, there is a fast and loose quality to them. I have read articles recently shaded to indicate Lewis’ implication in the murder and some that are flat out false.

There is prejudice here. It is undeniable that many associate Lewis’ case with the Simpson case. They fill in the parts they don’t know with details from OJ’s eventual acquittal.

Here are five common misconceptions about the murder case involving Ray Lewis:

1.  Ray Lewis was involved in a murder – Ray Lewis was an eventual witness in a murder case. He was charged with the murder of Jacinth Baker and Richard Lollar along with his two companions Reginald Oakley and Joseph Sweeting. The murder charges stemmed from a vicious fight in Atlanta streets following a Super Bowl Party in 2000. Eventually, the case ended with the defendants acquitted for reasons of self defense. In the eyes of the court, no murder took place.

2. Ray Lewis’ friends went to jail to protect him – This is in a lot of blogs and opinion pieces. It’s just not true. No one in this case went to jail.

3. Ray Lewis refused to testify against his friends in the murder trial – It’s the opposite. Ray Lewis started the trial at the table with Oakley and Sweeting. He flipped, pleading down to an obstruction of justice charge in exchange for testimony. Lewis was the state’s star witness. Some sources say the three men were no longer friends because of the alleged betrayal. Ironically, the only person to serve any sentence in this case at all was Lewis. Had he not flipped, he likely would have walked away with the same acquittal as the other defendants.

4. The murders were never solved – This is written a lot, along with something to the effect that no other suspects were ever arrested. It doesn’t seem to be in dispute that Oakley and Sweeting killed Baker and Lollar. The jury found that it was self defense after only a few hours of deliberation.

5. Ray Lewis is a murderer – Ray wasn’t involved in the fight that killed the two men. His companions were. Lewis wanted no part of the fight, but not for some moral or noble reason. He wanted to avoid the conflict because he was concerned it might hurt his NFL career. Throughout the process, Lewis seemed consumed with protecting his then burgeoning NFL superstar status. He made them promise silence in the limo afterward and lied to police the morning after. He flipped on his buddies to avoid scrutiny.

More from Eric Thomas

Comments (40)
  1. What are you, his lawyer? Here’s a couple of tidbits you apparently forgot in your gallant effort to defend this piece of garbage:

    1. Several witnesses say Lewis took part in the fight, which directly contradicts Lewis’ testimony that he wasn’t involved. Think about it: How credible is it that this big, tough NFL linebacker just stood passively by and watched as his friends were being beaten up anyway?

    2. Art Modell’s first impulse upon hearing the news was not to find out what happened, but to find Lewis a lawyer. For all he knew at that point, Lewis killed both men himself, and Modell’s response was to lawyer him up.

    We saw shades of this behavior from the same organization over a decade later, when another Ray (Rice) punched his wife in the face in an elevator and knocked her unconscious. Rice was honest from day one about what he did, and the team didn’t fine, suspend or punish him at all. They only released him after the video of the incident went public. Until that time, they were perfectly content to have a wife-beater on their team.

    3. Ray Lewis hired private investigators who managed to contact most of the major witnesses before the police did. Perhaps not surprisingly, the witnesses lawyered up, and, in the case of Duane Fassett, the limo driver who initially told cops he saw Lewis involved in the fight, suddenly developed memory problems about what happened.

    4. Blood was found on Ray Lewis’s pillowcase and on his bathrobe at his hotel the day after the murders. He claims the blood on his pillowcase was from a football injury, even though his team had been eliminated and he hadn’t played football for weeks by that time, and he claims to have no idea how the blood got on his bathrobe.

    5. Two different witnesses saw someone get out of the limousine and throw a bag into a trash bin after the murders. No one has ever found the suit Ray Lewis’ suit was wearing that night. Lewis has no explanation for where the suit is. What do you suppose he’s hiding?

  2. Bob Robison says:

    Ray Lewis was not acquitted. Ray Lewis plea bargained out of murder charges and the other charges were dropped. There is a big difference! While it is not right to call him a murderer it would be quite appropriate to call him an alleged murderer.

    This is an example of some terrible journalism!

    Want to break a real story? Tell us what Ray Lewis paid to the Baker’s family. I suspect a lot of money to shut up this story.

Leave a Reply to Will Smith Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

More From CBS Baltimore

Track Weather On The Go With Our App!
CBS All Access

Watch & Listen LIVE