Scott, Jeremy and Jason got into the debate about Los Angeles Dodgers pitcher Clayton Kershaw, and whether he should even be considered for the MLB Most Valuable Player award. Jeremy is in strong support of Pittsburgh Pirates Centerfielder Andrew McCutchen winning the award. In Conn’s belief, no pitcher should be eligible for the award.

On the other side of things Scott and Jason believe that Kershaw deserves the award. The Cy Young winner set historic numbers and carried a Dodgers team to the NL West crown. The argument even spilled over to the callers who got involved. Jonathon from Essex went toe to toe  with Jeremy claiming that Kershaw should win the award. So you tell us, should a pitcher win the Most Valuable player award?